In the near future water falls from the sky whenever someone lies (either a mist or a torrential flood depending on the intensity of the lie). This makes life difficult for Matt as he maneuvers the marriage question with his lover and how best to “come out” to his traditional Chinese parents.“Coming out would have hurt less a decade ago and it’ll hurt less now than a decade from now. Unless I just keep quiet and wait for my entire family to die off. Now there’s a cheery thought.”I've been on the...

This story raised some controversy when it won the 2014 Hugo Awards as apparently some readers thought it's not science fiction. Before I address this, let me just say the story is absolutely lovely.Some time in the near future, water starts falling on people whenever they tell a lie. It can be just a bit of water, or a downpour, or a simple humidifying of the air, depending on the intensity of the lie. And all this weaves into the story of Matt, a Chinese-American man, struggling to come out to...

I started crying partway through reading this beautiful story.

I first read this in new year minutes before some family relatives come to my house, so this story has an impact due to read it at the right time.But I barely found any science fiction or even fantasy element of this story, except the brief concept of a child of gay couple in one of the dialog. I found the family drama and MM romance were okay, but the main issue for me: the drama was not gripping my emotion, it felt like a regular family time. Compared to my own family-time, not much difference...

“I love you, Matt” doesn’t count as a powerful statement that holds true for all time and space. Except when Gus says it, apparently.this tor shorty is getting a lot of reactionary frowns and cranky reviews because it won a hugo award for best short story back in 2014 and it's not really sci-fi. which is a perfectly legitimate complaint, but one that didn't stop me from loving it because i didn't even know about the "scandal" before i read it, and because i actually prefer things that are more g...

fun and mysterious, with a great sense of style. dinged a star for the condom thing. don't normalize war-time best practices in a time of peace. it's not normal to treat your fiancé the same way you'd treat a grindr hookup.

My book club read a selection of short stories this month; this was one of them. This is a very well-crafted piece; and all the relationships in it ring very true. It's the story of a gay man struggling with coming out to his family during a holiday visit (this is a great story to read for Christmas!)I like that just about nothing here is idealized or sanitized - people are difficult, hard, irrational - but at the same time, the overall mood is sweet and hopeful.However, I disagree with this sto...

“I love you, Matt” doesn’t count as a powerful statement that holds true for all time and space. Except when Gus says it, apparently. I have always felt that crafting a short story is far more difficult than a full-length novel. You have so much to say, so many people to introduce and so many ideas to explore in such a small number of words. But it also means, that no word is wasted. Everything is profound. Huge amounts of genius and creativity compressed in such a small space, a good short

This love story is just so pure and heartwarming, I didn’t want it to get over. Gus is a sweetheart and Matt maybe a bit scared but his heart is true. I liked everyone except Matt’s sister and I don’t care if she loves him, but she is a bully. I also liked how fascinating this world was, and how everyone had to maneuver the way they spoke, hedging between truth and lies, so that they don’t get drenched in water. It’s a real dilemma and makes us realize how difficult it is to be truthful 100% of

One of the more effective approaches to writing a speculative fiction short story, it seems, is to come up with one clever element and then speculate on how that would influence every aspect of life. Ted Chiang does this very well in his story The Truth of Fact, The Truth of Feeling, which was nominated for a Hugo Award for Best Novelette this year (2014). Aliette de Bodard did it very well in her story Immersion, which was nominated for a slew of awards last year. And John Chu does it very well...

Chu looks at family both the blood one and the other ones we make as we grow. Families that we love and hate at the same time, families that pulls us here and there but the ropes that tie us cannot so easily be untied and we would feel adrift if they're cut.Don't know if I can call this sci-fi or fantasy anyway what's in a name. The premise and it's permutations are very very interesting and the piece is very well written, so much so that eventhough I'd have loved a translation to all the Chines...

This short was nominated for a Hugo in 2014. This award is for science fiction and fantasy. I saw very little of this in this story. In fact, i think it was just added to make a 'coming out story' accessible for an award. The story was boring and i had zero interest in it. The only fantasy element was water appears if a lie was told.The writing may be good, but the story is boring.

"The Water falls from the sky if you lie"............... is a creative means to tell your parents (or not) if you are gay. If you lie --water falls from the sky! -- Love is love is love! To hide it is a lie --don't ya think? Family complexity -relationships tender! .......and love between Matt and Gus is pure as water! The cover and title caught my attention! It can be read online --for free. Every Sunday morning I need to sit upright -or stand -for an hour after taking my bone density medicati...

I read this as part of the Hugo nomination packet, and am somewhat baffled. It's well written, I suppose, and there is a nominal science fiction element, though I'm tempted to instead check the box to shelve it as "magical realism." Apparently a few months ago, water started falling on people from nowhere whenever they tell a lie. If you're a little evasive, you get damp. If you tell a whopper, you get drenched. This just happens and there's no explanation, and it serves no purpose in the story

After the title of this story grabbed my attention, the art-work and synopsis enticed it further.The Water That Falls on You from Nowhere is a drama that can categorize into the genre of Bizarro. The simple fantasy theme belying it is that there's a downpour on every person who utters a lie and, depending on the severity of a lie, can turn into a drizzle, humidity, or even a torrent. The science and visual information behind this phenomenon has been denied to the readers because the sole focus i...

Finally a 5 stars short story!!! I simply loved this. The water was a further element to glimpse into the characters' feelings, something that can be hard to accomplish in such short stories, but here even without the water everyone was so well fleshed out that I didn't even feel like it was necessary. Still a really cool concept though and I think everyone can see it as a metaphor for whatever they wish and whatever comes closer to their personal experience.TW: homophobia, emotionally abusive s...

There's something clever about this story. Water that falls on you from nowhere...when you are fibbing. The conceit is the narrator is an in the closet gay, at least to his parents, and without the ability to lie to them since the water started falling, is faced with the conflict of how he is going to keep up the facade in front of his aged parents over the Christmas holidays when any lie he tells will be given away by...water, falling out of nowhere.Clever, right?Right. But science fiction? Joh...

What a concept: water falls from the sky if you lie. It's cold too. And if your lie is to your lover, he gets drenched too. Is that what love is? Sharing the cold and chilling, as well as the warm and comforting?I loved this short story. It had a structure to it that this math major appreciated.Thanks Elyse for sharing your review so that I could share the story too.I found this story on tor.com by entering John Chu in the search box. Its even appropriate for Christmas Day as the story takes pla...

rep: Chinese gay mc, gay li, Chinese characterstw: abuse and homophobia from siblinghello i am crying, yes

Ahoy there mateys! This 22 page 2014 Hugo award-winning short story was absolutely wonderful. Of course as it is from Tor.com I was expecting it to be. In this version of the future, telling a lie causes water to fall from the sky. How much water depends on how big the lie. This phenomena brings Matt a whole additional set of concerns about coming out to his traditional Chinese parents. I really enjoyed this quick read and absolutely loved the ideas and thoughts around telling lies. What crazy c...